01Start with age and parts
Age matters mostly because of parts and refrigerant. A unit well inside its normal service life with an available, affordable part is usually worth repairing. An older unit with an obsolete control board or a refrigerant that is no longer common becomes a different conversation.
02The cost ratio that settles most arguments
A workable rule: if the repair costs more than about half the price of a comparable replacement, and the unit is already well into its life, replacement is usually the better spend. Below that, repair. Either way, ask what the repair includes and whether the rest of the system is sound.
03Usually worth repairing
- Thermostat, thermistor or temperature sensor failure
- Defrost timer, element or fan failure
- Condenser or evaporator fan motor
- Start relay and capacitor
- Door seal, hinge or gasket
- Blocked drain or a drain heater
04Often not worth repairing
- Compressor failure on an old unit, where the part plus labour approaches replacement cost
- A leaking evaporator buried in foam insulation
- Corroded-through cabinets and base panels on coastal units
- Repeated leaks in a circuit that has already been repaired twice
- Obsolete controls with no available replacement
05The coastal factor
In Hout Bay, corrosion changes the maths. A unit whose cabinet base and condenser have rusted through is unlikely to give good service even after an electrical repair, because the next failure is already forming. When we quote a repair on coastal equipment we look at the whole unit, not only the failed part.
06Before you scrap it
- Confirm the diagnosis, not just the symptom
- Ask what the repair costs including labour and callout
- Check the replacement's dimensions fit the space and the doorways
- Ask about disposal and whether the old unit is collected
- For commercial units, check whether the replacement changes your electrical or ventilation requirements